Total Truth Radio

Magic

6 Apr 2014

My Mercian Diary Part 1 -The Staffordshire Hoard

Yesterday I was at Birmingham Museum and Art Gallery looking at and yet again marvelling over the Staffordshire Hoard....a discovery that has changed our view of the so-called Dark Ages in the British Isles between the Roman's finally leaving these shores completely in 450 AD and the arrival of the Norman invaders in 1066 - or to some historians considerably later than that.
For many years now I have argued against the idea that there was ever really a Dark Age in Britain and although by the end of Roman rule the country was certainly in turmoil with multiple violent incursions by the Picts, the Angles, the Jutes, the Saxons and the Irish (i.e. the proto-Scots)...it was open season in the struggle to take over these southern fertile lands that later became known as Engla Land....and later still England.

The first point to note here I think is that later official histories and national mythmakers suggest the period between the two Conquests must have been dark and a cessation of civilisation in these islands because they could not see (or were blind to) any evidence of the complex culture of Saxon England during the period that resulted in the country being eventually founded by King Athelstan as a unified nation state in 927.

This is a theory that doesn't any longer stand up, if indeed it ever did?

The so-called Dark Ages were not only about events taking place in Britain but also in Europe as a whole in what I have come to view as the imperial history of Britain and the world. According to Wikipedia for example... the Dark Ages was "originally the term (which) characterized the bulk of the Middle Ages, or roughly the 6th to 13th centuries, as a period of intellectual darkness between extinguishing the "light of Rome" after the end of Late Antiquity, and the rise of the Italian Renaissance in the 14th century." This wider definition is from the fall of the Western Roman Empire, the arrival of modernity and the origins of capitalism after the collapse of feudalism in late Medieval Britain.

However... when the term "Dark Ages" is used by historians today says Wikipedia, "it is intended to be neutral, namely, to express the idea that the events of the period often seem "dark" to us because of the paucity of historical records compared with both earlier and later times."



Imperial historiography has a history going back at least as far as Cornelius Tacitus [c. AD 56 – after 117] who was a politican (senator) and a foremost historian of the early Roman Empire and one of the very few sources of contemporaneous information about ancient Britain and its inhabitants, although it must be remembered for Tacitus and for Romans in general, Britain was the ideologicical counterpoint to Rome, the land of Barbarians on the edge of the world. The origin of the noble savage that fascinated and repelled Romans in equal measure, was a sort of imagined ancient Manson Family living in a world devoid of luxury, taste and sophistication and illogically in Roman terms, determined to defend their backwardness even to the death. Britons were the Roman untermenschen with a role in their empire not much different to that of the negro in the much more recent British empire whose founders ironically were thought of as less than fully human by the Roman occupying power at the time. Britain served as a perfect foil to Rome in Tacitus's day that demonstrated just how comfortable and superior the Roman urban elite saw themselves to be in contrast with the barabrians of the far northern isles. Here we find the origins of the 'Light of Rome' theory which contrasted with the assumed darkness that must have happened when that light was finally extinguished in these wild and distant hinterlands of the Roman Empire, according to the official (school/popular culture) history that was hegemonic throughout Britain's own imperial period and in its immediate aftermath.

Modern history and archaeology has progressively disconfirmed the alleged darkness of the period beyond any hope of it retaining any usefulness as a concept today, but nowhere is this more graphically illustrated than in the Staffordshire Hoard, discovered in 2009 in a field in Hammerwich in the English Midlands, the old Anglo-Saxon Kingdom of Mercia, or the modern county of  south Staffordshire.

FACTIOD

As it happens, I used to live in Burntwood, about a mile from where this treasure was discovered and during the mid-1970s I used to pass it every day (obviously unbeknownst to me) on my way to work on the railway in Walsall, a nine mile bicycle ride away. I am still slightly shocked that this treasure was almost on my doorstep where it had lain for about 1300 years when I lived in south Staffordshire during the early to mid 1970s, all the time lying just below the surface of a local field I passed almost every day. Such treasure was so close (to me) and yet for every generation since it was buried and right up almost to now... so very far away. 

Makes me wonder what treasure still lies undiscovered beneath our feet?

Here is what I failed to discover but am pleased that now it has come to light we know much more about Mercia and Anglo-Saxon England during the transition from paganism to christianity, a cultural revolution in progress captured in a time capsule that is the Staffordhire Hoard.....Enjoy!



5 comments:

  1. Thanks for this informative glimpse of the priceless Staffordshire Hoard, AA. Were I in your shoes I would love to go back in time right now (tricky thing, that) and show up in that very field you cycled by on the way to work--then have a go at the field with a metal detector! It could then become the Aardvark Hoard, and certainly worth a blog or three.

    It is interesting to find the whole idea of "Dark Ages" has become less about the lack of craftsmanship and sophistication in what scholars and researchers are studying, and more about what we moderns simply haven't discovered yet!

    I remember in a Medieval History class in school seeing some intricate examples of Celtic gold work in a film about Ireland in the era associated with The Book of Kells. It now appears to me that Saxony civilization in and around Mercia was also far more advanced in this art (and at least for far longer) then perhaps even experts expected.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your comments Doug. I know you are an accomplished time traveller yourself, but not so I unfortunately. The person who found the hoard has been richly rewarded for their efforts I undertand.
    To think that could have been me if only I'd invested in a metal detector and got off my bike in the right place. It only goes to show the serendipidy of good fortune and the profound unjustness of existence per se in my view Doug. A missed opportunity, oh well that's the way it goes sometimes I suppose.....It is interesting that you should mention The Book of Kells and those early Irish artistic and literary accomplishments, because I first started to seriously challenge the idea of a 'Dark Age' after I visited the 6th century monastic community of Glendalough in County Wicklow around 30-odd years ago.
    Its amazingly high round tower and other buildings represent a seat of learning art and culture that thrived in Ireland during the so-called Dark Ages and spread outwards from there. Further visits to places like the 7th century Lindisfarne in northeast England a centre for Celtic Christianity with its own illuminated gospels, it was a sort of proto-university in the wilds of ancient Northumberland before the Norse terror turned up. On the west side of what is now Scotland Iona fulfilled a similar function as a Celtic Christian enclave.
    In the 7th and 8th centuries the Venerable Bede England's first and most accomplished early historian again demonstrating the learning and sophistication that shines like a light undimmed against the backdrop of Norman propaganda that first gave rise to the Dark Ages myth in England. This myopic and arrogant view of the past has never held water set when against all the evidence stacked up that disconfirms it, but still it persisted as a prejudice in mainstream 'imperial' history until comparatively recently. The Staffordshire hoard merely underlines the errors of past historiography and gives us a tangible expression of the sophistication of the ealy Medieval period in Mercia, England, Britain and western Europe as a whole.
    Thanks again for your comments Doug, they are as always much appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They certainly didn't call him the Venerable Bede for nothing, AA!

      The American Thomas Cahill, another very interesting historian, wrote an interesting book in the 1990's called "How the Irish Saved Civilization", a popular history which talks about the illuminated Gospels and the islands in the North and Irish Sea like Ionia where many manuscripts were saved and lovingly copied for future use by "university monks" as it were before the bad times from the Norse started up.

      If there is some bad propaganda about that period in the British Isles, I should have known the Normans were at the bottom of it. 'Whomever controls the present controls the past' as Orwell said.

      Thank you AA, for sharing your journeys such places as Lindisfarne.

      Delete
  3. The view that the Irish saved western civilisation is a common one in Ireland unsurprsingly and I am not surprised that an ex-patriot Jesuit might hold such a view quite strongly. There is some truth in the statement in that Irish monasticism held sway in what is now Scotland and northern England until it collided with the Roman Church at the Synod of Whitby in 664 which heralded the Romanisation of British christianity and another competitor to the 'civilisation' claim at that time. It is indeed timely that this discussion should crop up on the the day before Easter Sunday (Holy Saturday) because it was the calculation of Easter and Nicene Creed that caused the conflict between Rome and the Celtic church. Interestingly at the time of Whitby the Irish church had already adopted the Roman form of Easter anyway leaving outposts like Iona and Lindisfarne arguing for things given up in the mother country. The complex interplay between these and the incoming Norse threats retained art and crafts at their centre throughout the dangerous violent era of Viking incursions and local conflicts. The Staffordshire hoard bears witness to this cultural continuity I think and global trade, the garnet came from what is now the Czech Republic and possibly Afghanistan. During the time we are taling about here Queen Aethelflaed of Mercia was redesignining and rebuilding the still existing city centre street grid of Gloucester in Mercia. So I think the bigger picture gives Ireland an important role in the preservation and development of early Medieval European culture Doug, but to say Ireland saved civilisation is a bit overstated to say the least in my view. The founder of the university of Celtic Christianity the 6th century at Glendalough, the hermit St Kevin was a misogynistic homicidal maniac according to a popular legend that he drowned a women who tried to seduce him. All good stuff Doug, thanks for taking the topic onto an Easter trajectory.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for filling in the gaps left open by popular historians, AA.

    ReplyDelete